CONCEPT AND ESSENCE OF CONSTITUTIONAL CONTROL IN UKRAINE
Author (s): Stashkiv B.I., Tiutiunnyk А.V.
Work place:
Stashkiv B. І.,
Ph.D. in Law, Associate Professor, Associate Professor of the Department of State and Law Theory and History, Constitutional Law,
Academy of the State Penitentiary Service, Chernihiv, Ukrаine
ORCID: 0000-0003-3746-9382;
Tiutiunnyk А. V.,
Officer of the 361-st academic group,
Academy of the State Penitentiary Service, Chernihiv, Ukraine
ORCID: 0000-0001-5651-7648
Language: Ukrainian
Criminal Executive System: Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow. 2020. № 2 (8): 74-83
https://doi.org/10.32755/sjcriminal.2020.02.074
The theoretical prerequisites are analyzed in the article along with practice of the institution functioning of constitutional control. There are studies about the concepts and features of constitutional control and the relationship with the concepts of “constitutional supervision” and “constitutional justice”. The study established that constitutional control, being a specific means of protecting the Constitution, acts as a specialized mechanism, a system for ensuring the constitution as a normative legal act of higher legal force, and a kind of control as a corresponding function. The concept of constitutional control has been defined, in particular, and its definition should be understood as the power granted to the relevant body to control and, if necessary, establish the conformity or inconsistency with the Constitutional acts adopted by various public authorities, and especially the laws adopted by representative institutions. The forms of constitutional control and tendencies of their development are examined, the place of constitutional control in the modern state-legal mechanism is also determined. The content of constitutional review is determined by the nature of the bodies that exercise it. There are two main systems or models of constitutional control: “American” and “European” one.
It is determined in the article that the place of constitutional control in the system of state institutions in the legal literature is due to the fact that the bodies of constitutional control are not included in any of the branches of government, they can be included in a special one, the fourth branch – which is control.
The authors made a distinction between the concepts of “constitutional control” and “constitutional justice”. It was found out what is connected with the transfer of new, previously unknown powers to specialized bodies of constitutional jurisdiction. In this regard, the constitutional control carried out by the courts of special jurisdiction consists solely in assessing the compliance of an act or activity with the Fundamental Law.
Key words: constitutional control, constitutional supervision, constitutional justice, forms of constitutional control, state-legal mechanism.
References
- Valkova, А. І. (2015), “The legal nature of constitutional control of the same place in the state-legal mechanism”, Law and society, Issue 3, pp. 9–12.
- Klishas, А. А. (2007), Constitutional review and constitutional justice in foreign countries: avtoref. dys. … dokt. yuryd. nauk.
- Fedorenko, V. V. (2014), “Implementation of the constitutional principles of justice in the status and activities of the bodies of constitutional jurisdiction of Ukraine and foreign countries”, Current issues of state and law, Issue 73, pp. 201–207.
- Maryniv, І. І. (2013), Constitutional control in the Republic of Poland: monograph, Law, Kharkiv.
- Kelman, М. S. (2015), Constitutional control as a means of protection and legal systems of continental law: avtoref. dys. … dokt. yuryd. Nauk : 12.00.02, National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Koretsky V. M. Іnstitute of State and Law, Kyiv.
- Maryniv, І. І. (2012), Constitutional control in the Republic of Poland: avtoref. dys. … dokt. yuryd. nauk: 12.00.02, National University “National Yaroslav Mudryi Law Academy of Ukraine”, Kharkiv.
- Huliamova, D. R. (2000), Institute of constitutional control in the political system. World experience and Kazakhstan: avtoref. dys. …. kand. polit. nauk., Almaty.
- Kharytonova, N. N. (2006), “Constitutional justice in the CIS and Baltic countries”, Digest of official materials and publications of periodicals, Issue 2, pp. 95–100.
- Horsheniova M. S., Zakomorna, K. O., Riaka, V. O. (2007), Constitutional law of foreign countries: manual / in Riaka, V.O. (Ed.). 2-nd edit., Yurinkom Inter, Kyiv.
- Dubrova, О. B. (2011), “Concepts, subjects and types of constitutional control”, Tribune of the dissertation obtainer, Issue 12, pp. 88–97.