GENERAL ISSUES AND CERTAIN FEATURES OF TERMINOLOGICAL FORMULATIONS AND SPECIAL RULES OF SENTENCING
Author (s): Denysova T.A., Denysov S.F., Bilokoniev V.M.
Work place:
Denysova T.A.,
Doctor of Sciences (Law), Professor,
Honored Lawyer of Ukraine
Assistant of the President for Science and Methodology,
Academy of the State Penitentiary Service, Chernihiv, Ukraine
Denysov S.F.,
Doctor of Sciences (Law), Professor,
Head of the Department of Criminal, Criminal and Executive Law and Criminology
Academy of State Penitentiary Service, Chernihiv, Ukraine
Bilokonev V.M.,
Judge of Zaporizhzhia Appeal Court
Language: Ukrainian
Criminal Executive System: Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow.2018. № 2 (4): 92-107
https://doi.org/10.32755/sjcriminal.2018.02.092
The article deals with general issues of punishment that are important for the theory of criminal law and law-enforcement practice, approaches to determining its essential features, special rules for imposing punishment for an incomplete crime and a crime committed in complicity, taking into account when sentencing the severity of the person’s act, the degree of criminal intent and certain features of the terminological formulations used in sentencing, in particular, “separate episodes of criminal activity” that are a part of complex single crimes or are separate compositions of identical crimes and are part of replication as forms of multiple crimes.
It was stated that, taking into account the current state of the dynamics and tendencies of the spread of crimes, a necessary law to strengthen the rule of law is the criminal law designed to combat crime by bringing to justice the perpetrators and sentencing them.
It is indicated that punishment is one of the means of preventing crime. Among all measures of state coercion, it is the most stringent and is used only for committing socially dangerous acts. Issues have been identified that remain insufficiently studied or have not found their final solution, in particular: signs of punishment; purpose (goal) punishment; ascertaining which criminal law measures should be deemed appropriate for achieving the goal of punishment; issues of imbalance of sanctions in separate norms; law enforcement practice in sentencing on the basis of Part 1 of Article 70 and Part 4 of Article 70 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine in the presence of the actions of a person “separate episodes of criminal activity”.
The main signs of punishment are defined. 1. Punishment is a measure of state coercion that is provided for only by law and is applied on behalf of the state by the relevant government body. 2. Punishment can only be applied to a person convicted of a crime under criminal law. 3. Punishment is applied on behalf of the state only by the relevant authority – the court and appointed by conviction. 4. Punishment is a penalty imposing restrictions on the rights and freedoms of a convicted person, imposes an obligation on the convicted person to bear the losses and restrictions associated with his application. 5. Punishment is the logical legal consequence of a crime. 6. Punishment is public. 7. Punishment entails a special legal consequence – a conviction.
Sentences for the unfinished crime and for the crime committed in complicity, which is settled in Article 68 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine and applies to special rules of sentencing, are examined.
The range of issues related to the terms used in the legislation and requiring unambiguous interpretation has been determined. In particular, the terminological turnover “separate episodes of criminal activity” was analyzed, as well as the specialized term “criminal activity”. It is noted that in sentencing, the possibility of correct interpretation of the relevant norm becomes of particular importance.
Key words: punishment, sentencing, crime, severity of the act, unfinished crime, complicity, separate episodes of criminal activity.
References
- Dzhuzha, O.M., Savchenko, A.V. and Cherniei, V.V. (2016), Scientific and Practical Commentary of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, Yurinkom Inter, Kyiv.
- Denysova, T. A. (2008), in Stashys, V.V. (Ed.), Criminal punishment: tasks and functions, practice of application. The legal system of Ukraine: history, state and prospects: 5 volumes. Vol. 5: Criminal and legal sciences. Actual problems of fight against crime in Ukraine, Pravo, Kharkiv, рр. 208–219.
- Denysova, T.A. (2017), in Tatsii, V.Ya. and Borysov, V.I. (еd.), Punishment, its concept and purpose. Great Ukrainian Law Encyclopedia: 20 volumes. Vol. 17: Criminal Law, National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine; V. M. Koretsky Institute of State and Law of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Yaroslav Mudryi National Law Unversity, рр. 709–713.
4. Bekkaria, Ch. (1995), On crimes and punishments, Stels, Moscow. 5. Denysova, T.A. (2017), in Tatsii, V.Ya. and Borysov, V.I. (еd.), Appointment of punishment for a pending crime and for a crime committed in complicity.Great Ukrainian Law Encyclopedia: 20 volumes. Vol. 17: Criminal Law, National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine; V. M. Koretsky Institute of State and Law of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Yaroslav Mudryi National Law Unversity, рр. 798–800.6. Kvasha, O.O. (2013), Participation in crime: structure and responsibility: a monograph, National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, V. M. Koretsky Institute of State and Law, Luhansk State University of Internal Affairs named after E.O. Didorenko, Luhansk.7. Ukraine (2004), Bulletin of the legislation and legal practice of Ukraine, Kyiv.8. Zelinskiy, A.F. (1978), “The concept of “criminal activity”, Soviet state and law, No.10, рр. 98–100.9. Zelinskiy, A.F. (1979), “Some issues concerning criminal activity qualification”, Proceedings of the Higher Investigative School of the USSR Ministry of Internal Affairs, Vol. 11, рр. 27–32, Volgograd.10. Zelinskyi, A.F. (1991), “Criminal Activity: Concept and Responsibility”, Soviet law, No.12, рр. 32–35. 11. Zelinskyi, A.F. and Korzhanskyi, M.Y. (1998), Mercenary criminal activity, Genesa,Kyiv.12. Zelinskiy, A.F. (1999), Criminal Psychology, Yurinkom Inter, Kiev.13. Navrotskyi, V.O. (2006), Fundamentals of criminal and law qualification, Yurinkom Inter, Kyiv.
- Dzhuzha, O.M., Savchenko, A.V. and Cherniei, V.V. (2011), Qualification of crimes, investigated by internal affairs bodies: A manual, Atika, Kyiv.
15. Russia (1999), The course of criminal law. A common part. Volume 1: Teaching about a crime, Publishing house Zertsalo, Moscow.
- Trostiuk, Z.A. (2003), Conceptual apparatus of the Special Part of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, Atika, Kyiv.