WAYS OF IMPROVING REGULATORY AND LEGAL ENFORCEMENT OF COURT DECISIONS REGARDING CONVICTS IN PLACES OF IMPRISONMENT
Author (s): Hnatchuk A.
Work place:
Hnatchuk A.,
Post graduate student of the Department of Criminal-Legal
and Administrative-Legal Disciplines,
Academician Stepan Demianchuk International University
of Economics and Humanities,
Rivne, Ukraine
ORCID: 0009-0001-3038-2287
Language: Ukrainian
Criminal Executive System: Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow. 2023. № 2 (14): 46–57
https://doi.org/10.32755/sjcriminal.2023.02.046
The article states that the Russian-Ukrainian war had a profound impact on important state decisions regarding the reform of the criminal justice system and its transformation into a penitentiary system. This was especially evident with the opening of new correctional colonies for prisoners of war of the Russian Federation and the serving of punishment for war crimes as servicemen of the armed forces of the Russian Federation and collaborators among citizens of Ukraine.
The improvement of legal and regulatory enforcement of court decisions regarding convicts in places of imprisonment is determined by the need to revise the existing legal and regulatory framework, with the aim of bringing it into line with the new needs of the socio-economic and political-legal development of Ukraine.
It is noted that the following problems have been identified in the practical sphere of bodies and institutions for the execution of punishments in terms of the execution of court decisions regarding convicts in places of imprisonment:
- a) the execution of court decisions by prison personnel is complicated by the fact that the bodies and institutions for the execution of punishments receive court decisions on various categories of convicts: first-time convicts, previously convicted, women, men, minors, and therefore their reception has its own peculiarities;
- b) description of the mechanism of execution of court decisions by the staff of places of imprisonment in the precedent practice of the Supreme Court and its analysis in terms of harmonization with national legislation and the practice of the ECHR;
- c) ensuring the correct interpretation of the mechanism of execution of court decisions by the staff of places of imprisonment and developing the necessary legislative initiatives on this basis;
- d) working out the mechanisms for the execution of court decisions by the staff of places of imprisonment by improving the criminal-executive legislation, taking into account the content of its reformatory changes, introduced amendments, prescriptions of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, provisions of international legal acts, decisions of the ECHR and the precedent practice of the Supreme Court, which are often in the situation dynamic changes and incomplete systematization.
The solution to these problems requires the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine to introduce legislative amendments to improve the current criminal-executive legislation, corrections to the functioning of the criminal-executive system, cooperation with state and non-state organizations as part of the proper execution of court decisions regarding convicts in places of imprisonment.
Our analysis of the source base of the research proved the need to develop an effective concept of execution of court decisions regarding convicts in Ukraine, as various difficulties arise in practice, the causes of which are both the imperfection of domestic legislation and the reluctance of the staff of the penal institutions to comply with them.
The need to introduce changes and additions to the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and the current legal acts of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine regarding the improvement of the proper execution of court decisions regarding convicts in Ukraine is substantiated.
Key words: improvement, execution, court decision, convict, places of imprisonment.
References
- Ukraine (2022), On approval of the Penitentiary System Reform Strategy for the period until 2026 and approval of the operational plan for its implementation in 2022–2024: Decree of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine, available at: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1153-2022-%D1%80#Text (accessed 8 October 2023).
- European penitentiary rules, available at: https://zakon.rada. gov.ua/laws/show/994_032#Text (accessed 8 October 2023).
- Puzyrov, M. S., Lysenko M. I. (2012), “Implementation of the principle of humanism in the execution and serving of punishment in conditions of isolation of convicts”, Law and society, № 6, pp. 141–145.
- Kaznacheeva, D. V. (2015), “The issue of parole from serving a sentence in the legislation of foreign countries”Current problems of criminal law and criminology in the side of criminal justice reform : materials of the international science and practice conf. (Kharkіv, May 22, 2015), Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs, Kharkiv, pp. 37–39.
- Denysov, S. F. and Aliev, R. V. (2015), “Conceptual bases of legal regulation of execution of punishments within the framework of the Model Criminal Code”, Actual problems of criminal law and criminology in the side of criminal justice reform : materials of the international. science and practice conf. (Kharkiv, May 22, 2015), Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs, Kharkiv, pp. 159–160.
- Razmetaeva, Yu. S. (2013), Human rights as a fundamental value of civil society, Finart, Kharkiv.
- Avtukhov, K. A. and Stepaniuk, A. Kh. (2015), The rights and legitimate interests of those sentenced to imprisonment under the conditions of the reform of the State Criminal Enforcement Service of Ukraine, Pravo, Kharkiv.
- Ukraine (1996), Constitution of Ukraine :Law of Ukraine, Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, Kyiv.
- Podlehaev, K. M. (2020), “Application of precedent practice of the European Court of Rights to strengthen the principle of presumption of innocence in the criminal process of Ukraine”, Visegrad Journal on Human Rights, № 3, pp. 153–156.
- Petrova, L. (1997), “Sources of law”, Bulletin of the Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine, № 1, pp. 65−76.
- Guralenko, N. A. (2009), Judicial precedent in the system of sources of law: philosophical and legal aspect : PhD in Law Thesis, Lviv.
- Novosad, Yu. O. (2019), The Prosecutor’s Office of Ukraine as a participant in criminal enforcement activities, Volyn Region Printing House, Lutsk.
- Ukraine (2014), On the Prosecutor’s Office : Law of Ukraine, Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, Kyiv.