MARGINALISM OR HUMANISM – MODERN APPROACHES TO ENSURING THE RIGHTS OF THOSE SENTENCED TO LIFE IMPRISONMENT IN UKRAINE: THE THEORETICAL AND LEGAL ASPECT OF THE ISSUE
Author (s): Kolb O., Levchenko Yu.
Work place:
Kolb O.,
Doctor of Sciences (Law), Professor, Honored Lawyer of Ukraine,
Professor of the Department of Criminal Justice,
State Tax University, Irpin, Ukraine
ORCID: 0000-0003-1792-4739;
Levchenko Yu.,
PhD in Law, Professor,
Head of the Department of Criminology
and Criminal and Executive Law,
National Academy of Internal Affairs,
Kyiv, Ukraine
ORCID: 0000-0003-1124-9517
Language: Ukrainian
Criminal Executive System: Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow. 2023. № 2 (14): 70–86
https://doi.org/10.32755/sjcriminal.2023.02.070
This scientific article clarifies the socio-normative nature of the legal status of those sentenced to life imprisonment, and also determines the influence of existing marginal groups (politicians, subjects of legislative initiative, scientists, practitioners, etc.) on the process of execution – serving this type of criminal punishment.
In particular, it was established that life imprisonment is applied by the court only in exceptional cases, when the purpose of punishment established in the Criminal Code of Ukraine cannot be achieved by other means of criminal law influence defined in the law.
Based on this, a special status of those sentenced to life imprisonment has been established at the legislative level, which provides for such legal restrictions that are not characteristic of other types of punishments associated with the isolation of persons guilty of crimes.
On the basis of the study of the content of national legal acts, the corresponding norms of international law, practice and theoretical studies, it was established that today the legal status of persons sentenced to life imprisonment, as well as the process of execution – serving this criminal punishment in full meets the requirements of civilization, the best foreign approaches and in general the socio-legal nature of the specified subjects of criminal-executive legal relations.
It has also been proven that any attempts by politicians and other subjects of the formation and implementation of the criminal law policy of Ukraine, including people’s deputies and scientists, should be regarded as the marginalization of the execution process – the serving of a sentence in the form of life imprisonment and the creation of another source that encroach on the national security of Ukraine.
Key words: marginalization; humanism; execution process – serving sentences; Legal Status; sentenced to life imprisonment; purpose of punishment; legal restrictions.
References
- Chebotarova, Yu. A. (2005), Legal status of those sentenced to imprisonment, Abstract of Ph.D. thesis, Kharkiv.
- Dzhuzha, O. M., etc. (2010), Criminal law of Ukraine : textbook, Atika, Kyiv.
- Kolb, O. H., etc. (2020), Application of measures of physical influence, special means and weapons to convicts deprived of liberty in Ukraine: legal grounds, theory and practice: training. manual, SPD Hadiak Zh. V. ; drukarnia «Volynpolihraf» TM., Lutsk.
- On the application of the Constitution of Ukraine in the administration of justice : resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of Ukraine dated November 1, 1996 No. 9: Resolutions of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of Ukraine in criminal cases, PALYVODA A. V., Kyiv.
- Review of decisions of the European Court of Human Rights (2011), Donetskyi Memorial, Donetsk.
- Lysodied, O. V. (2015), “Consolidation of international and European standards of treatment of convicts in the criminal law of Ukraine (on the example of the Law of Ukraine dated April 8, 2014, No. 1186-VII)”, The issue of fighting crime, Vol. 30, pp. 64–76.
- Avtukhov, K. A., Hel, A. P. and Yakovets, I. S. (2020), Criminal law of Ukraine. Academic course : textbook, Yurinkom Inter, Kyiv.
- Kolb, O. H. (2021), “On some conceptual principles of execution of punishments in the form of deprivation of liberty”, Bulletin of the Penitentiary Association of Ukraine, No. 1 (15), pp. 157–159.
- Puzyrov, M. S. (2018), Comparative analysis of the execution of a sentence in the form of imprisonment for a certain period in Ukraine and foreign countries : a monograph, Dakor, Kyiv.
- Akers, R. I. (1977), Deviant behavior. A social learning approach and ed, Wadsworth, Belmont.
- Kolb, O. H. and Duchyminska, L. M. (2020), “Modern policy in the field of execution of punishments of Ukraine: content and features”, Bulletin of the Penitentiary Association of Ukraine, No. 1 (11), pp. 55–64.